Year : 2018 | Volume
: 11 | Issue : 2 | Page : 89--90
Upper age limit for assisted reproductive technologies: Ethics opinion
Sujata Kar1, Duru Shah2, Madhuri Patil3,
1 Executive Member ISAR; Director, Kar Clinic & Hospital Pvt. Ltd., Bhubaneswar, Orissa, India
2 President Indian Society for Assisted Reproduction 2017-18; Director Gynaecworld the Center for Womenís Health and Fertility, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India
3 Editor, Journal of Human Reproductive Sciences; Clinical Director and Principal, Dr. Patilís Fertility and Endoscopy Clinic, Bengaluru, Karnataka, India
Indian Society for Assisted Reproduction, Flat No. 23 A, 2nd Floor, Elco Arcade, Hill Road, Bandra (West), Mumbai . 400 050, Maharashtra
Fertility in women is closely related to reproductive age and becomes significantly compromised before the onset of perimenopausal menstrual irregularity. There is decrease in oocyte quality with age which is reflected by the increase of chromosomal aberrations in the oocytes and embryos. Oocyte or embryo donation to women of advanced age should be discouraged.
|How to cite this article:|
Kar S, Shah D, Patil M. Upper age limit for assisted reproductive technologies: Ethics opinion.J Hum Reprod Sci 2018;11:89-90
|How to cite this URL:|
Kar S, Shah D, Patil M. Upper age limit for assisted reproductive technologies: Ethics opinion. J Hum Reprod Sci [serial online] 2018 [cited 2020 Nov 28 ];11:89-90
Available from: https://www.jhrsonline.org/text.asp?2018/11/2/89/238220
The natural limits to reproduction for women have been extended by available reproductive technologies. With oocyte and embryo donation, women well beyond menopausal age can aspire to give birth. Donation and hormonal treatments can medically overcome age-related decline in egg and embryo quality. However, significant dangers from age-related diseases remain which can complicate pregnancy.
Maternal and neonatal morbidity and mortality are significantly increased at advanced maternal ages. To avoid harm, fully informing women of the significant health risks and fetal risks, as part of counseling, is critical for informed consent.
In India, unregulated treatment has led to many “grandmother” mothers, with a very high morbidity for the woman and the neonates as well., The Indian Council of Medical research (ICMR) guidelines of 2005 states that the recipient “should be a healthy woman (determined by medical and psychological examination) having normal genitalia (as determined by physical examination) and uterine cavity (as determined by hysterosalpingography).”
The guidelines of the Ministry of Health, Government of India, 2005, have no recommendation on the upper age limit for recipients of donated oocytes or embryos. However, the 2017 ICMR draft bill for assisted reproductive technology (ART) suggests an upper age limit of 45 for women and 50 for men.
There is a need to determine when ART can be safely offered to women of advanced age and when it should be denied.
There are a number of considerations supporting childbearing for couples of advanced age, which are described as follows:
Average life expectancy in India has increased significantly from 58.3 in 1990 to 70 in 2015. Women are living well beyond menopause which is 47.5 (2008) in India. Rising life expectancy encourages women to become mothers at a later ageWomen may delay childbearing beyond their 40s for financial, career, and personal reasonsThere is no cutoff to define advanced age, but for women, it may be considered as age of natural menopause.
There are also considerations against childbearing in couples of advanced age, which are described as follows:
As age advances, there are higher chances of pregnancy-related complications which may become life-threatening, especially after the age of 55Preterm birth, low birth weight, genetic abnormalities, and higher fetal mortality increase with maternal age. Higher rates of genetic abnormalities also can be related to advanced paternal age. “Advanced paternal age” has not been defined though evidence exists of increased risks of disabilities and disorders resulting from single-gene mutations and chromosomal abnormalities in offspring of men of advancing ageSocial, economic, and medical fitness of the couple to raise a child to adulthood, at an advanced age, may be compromisedFamily support may diminish with advancing age. Younger family members may have their own children to focus on and may not have the capacity to provide additional support to elderly family members who are new parents or to the children born to themCompromised medical fitness in either partner leads to a higher risk of mortality and morbidity which may ultimately affect the well-being of the child. Loss of a parent is the worst kind of stress for any child and an acknowledged factor in diminishing their success in life.
The major ethical issues include whether the best medical interests (beneficence) and avoidance of harm in medical care (nonmaleficence) of the couple and the child thus born are served by pregnancy at advanced parental age. The ethical responsibility to assure careful medical evaluation with full counseling and informed consent is heightened, especially when there are increased risks for short- and long-term harm to patients and their offspring.
A health professional may ethically decline treatment to women of advanced maternal age based on their health status and the risk of potential harm to them or their offspringCouples of advanced age considering ART should be counseled about adoption as an additional option for child raisingFor women up to 45, ART could be offered after routine evaluation reveals that there are no underlying medical conditions that would significantly increase the obstetrical and neonatal risks. Expert opinion suggests that women up to 50 could potentially be medically considered with the same criteria for risk assessment based on the age of menopause and life expectancy. Additional counseling regarding the increased risks added by age for maternal and fetal health must be givenFor men up to 50, ART may be offered after routine evaluation reveals satisfactory parameters for sperm. Counseling regarding potential for genetic and other abnormalities needs to be providedIn all circumstances where oocyte or embryo donation is offered, a careful and truthful informed consent is necessaryGiven the high risk of pregnancy at advanced age, couples should be counseled about the need for access to high levels of maternal and neonatal care for the pregnancy.
This report was developed by the Ethics Working Group of the Indian Society for Assisted Reproduction as a service to its members and other practicing clinicians. While this document reflects the views of members of that committee, it is not intended to be the only approved standard of practice or to dictate an exclusive course of treatment in all cases. This report was reviewed by the Ethics Committee of the American Society for Reproductive Medicine and their input was considered in the preparation of the final document. We acknowledge Joanna Cain, Former Chair of the 'FIGO International Ethics Committee' for participation during the development of the ethics opinion as an International Advisor.
The following members of the ISAR Ethics Working Group have contributed in the development of this document.
Duru Shah, Madhuri Patil, Sujata Kar, Nalini Mahajan, Sadhana Desai, Ameet Patki, (Indian Society for Assisted Reproduction), Manohar Motwani (Private Practitioner), Sanjay Chauhan (Scientist F, ICMR-NIRRH), Hitesh Bhatt (Medico Legal Advisor), Amit Karkhanis (Legal Advisor), Anushree Patil (Scientist D, ICMR-NIRRH), Flavia Agnes (Lawyer and Activist), and Subarna Ghosh (Reproductive Activist).
We thank Abbott India Limited for their logistic support during the preparation of the Ethics Opinion.
Financial support and sponsorship
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
|1||Woman in her 70s may be oldest ever to give birth. Retrieved from https://www.cbsnews.com/news/woman-in-her-70s-may-be-oldest-ever-to-give-birth/. [Last accessed on 2018 Mar 01].|
|2||The world's oldest mother. Retrieved from https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2009/mar/06/fertility-problems-india. [Last accessed on 2018 Mar 01].|
|3||The Assisted Reproductive Technologies (regulation) draft rules – 2010; 2017 Indian Council of Medical Research New Delhi; Ministry of Health and Family Welfare Govt. Of India, New Delhi.|
|4||SRS Statistical Report 2013. Retrieved from http://www.censusindia.gov.in/Vital_Statistics/SRS_Life_Table/SRS_11-15/3. Analysis_2011-15.pdf. [Last accessed on 2018 Mar 01].|
|5||Unni J. Third consensus meeting of Indian Menopause Society: A summary (2008). J Mid-life Health 2010;1:43.|
|6||Oocyte or embryo donation to women of advanced reproductive age: An ethics committee opinion. Fertility and Sterility® Vol. 106, No. 5, October 2016 0015-0282.|